People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Joe and the staff are incredible here! They accommodated our entire soccer team plus family for a Friday night dinner and didn’t skip a beat on the amazing service and delicious apps, entrees, or desserts. And definitely get one of the most incredible mixologist-crafted cocktails! If you’re here on the island or visiting, be sure to try Smithtown Pasta House! ”
“ First time coming here and absolutely blown away. The atmosphere is beautiful. Highly recommend trying the crispy gnocchi appetizer. Our server Michelle was personable and attentive and made our first visit phenomenal. Everything was easily 10/10 & will definitely be coming back here. ”
“ My wife and I went to Pasta House for the first time Saturday evening. Great experience. Food was top notch, best vodka sauce I have ever had, service was outstanding and overall a nice atmosphere. Sue our server was exceptional and was so pleasant. Can’t wait to come back for the next meal. ”
“ The staff was very pleasant and very professional. Our waitress, Alex was outstanding. The food was to perfection and the ambiance was amazing. I will definitely be going back ”
“ Good food, had the chicken vodka parmigiana. It's very tasty. Flounder oregonato was okay, probably could have had more seasoning. Veal parmigiana was very good. Burrato pizza and calamari were both good. ”
“ We went to Smithtown Pasta house for my 37th birthday and I am so happy I picked it!! First, the staff is AMAZING! Michelle is beyond AMAZING! So personable and great at her job. We loved how open it was, but it still felt intimate. My family and I all had amazing dishes! I wish I took more pictures. We will def be back! I totally recommend going and seeing Michelle! ”
“ The Smithtown Pasta House transported my wife and I to Italy. The food was so authentic and delicious. I am also vegan and they even have a vegan dish and can easily modify most other dishes. Our waiter Lou was so friendly and attentive which made us enjoy our experience. Christie (Manager) was so friendly, came over to our table, introduced herself to us and asked us how everything was going which was so nice. The ambiance of the dining room was exquisite. I will be coming back !!!!! Did we say the food was OUTRAGEOUS!! My wife had the truffle mac and cheese and the linguini bolognese and I had beet salad, roasted artichokes, and pasta alla mama wow wow soooo good!!!!! Additional review....we loved Smithtown Pasta House so much we ordered take out. The staff meticulously timed the appetizers and entrees to be cooked so they were piping hot when we picked up the food. My guests were so impressed. They demolished their food said it was one of the best Italian places on long island. Christie took my order and I informed her that I would pick up the food at a specific time and sure enough my order was completed at the precise time I said!!! My food was hot out of the oven, each appetizer and entree was wrapped in plastic wrap to keep it hot, but most important the food was delicious. The portions were exactly the generous portions they gave us when we dined in the restaurant!!! Thank You Smithtown Pasta House for feeding my guests well. This place is incredible!!! A class of their own. We will be back. ”
“ Excellent service - food was delicious, a fun spot ”
Menu
Shrimp Cocktail
US$22.00Cannolis
US$14.00Vodka Sauce
US$20.00Chicken Rollatini
US$30.00Chicken Francaise
US$30.00
About
Smithtown Pasta House
Welcome to Smithtown Pasta House, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Smithtown, New York. Located at 65 E Main St, this inviting establishment has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With their exceptional service, delectable menu offerings, and warm ambiance, it’s no wonder that patrons rave about their experiences here.
From the moment you step through the doors, you’re greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that perfectly complements the artistry of their dishes. The incredibly talented staff, including standout servers like Joe, Michelle, and Sue, ensure that every dining experience is memorable. They go above and beyond to accommodate groups, making even the busiest evenings feel seamless and welcoming, as noted by satisfied customers like Sheetal Davitt.
Now, let’s talk food. The menu at Smithtown Pasta House is a true celebration of Italian cuisine. Must-try items include their crispy gnocchi appetizer, which has left first-time guests like Danielle O' utterly astounded. The creamy vodka sauce served with the pasta has been heralded as possibly the best in the area, with guests like Jamie Chronowitz expressing their delight in every savory bite. Whether you're indulging in their chicken vodka parmigiana or the delectable veal, the flavors are consistently impressive.
Beverage lovers will not want to miss out on the mixologist-crafted cocktails. As mentioned by Sheetal Davitt, these unique drinks are the perfect accompaniment to your meal, rounding out your dining experience with flair.
In addition to their delicious fare, the overall ambiance—a blend of comfort and elegance—makes Smithtown Pasta House an ideal spot for everything from family dinners to romantic evenings out. Guests have noted how the atmosphere enhances their experience, making every visit feel special.
In conclusion, Smithtown Pasta House not only excels in offering remarkable food but also creates lasting memories through outstanding service and a welcoming vibe. Whether you're a resident or just passing through Long Island, make sure to treat yourself to a meal here. You won’t be disappointed!
Book a table